In the last decade of the century, Giotto is employed at Assisi
in painting the cycle of frescoes depicting the stories of St. Francis.
The St. Francis cycle at Assisi is one of history's most clamorous cases of
an artistic masterpiece where there is a total lack of dependable dates about
when they were done and the artist (or artists) who did them. Identifying the
artist is one of the most complicated riddles in art history.
The first mention of Giotto's work at Assisi comes from Riccobaldo da Ferrara.
But it is Ghiberti (1450 ca) who first maintains that Giotto "painted almost
all the lower part" in the Church of the Asciesi, of the Minorite order.
The only information about who commissioned it is given by Giorgio Vasari in
the second edition of his Lives of the Artists (1568). There he affirms that
the cycle was painted when Fra Giovanni da Murro (1296-1304) was General of
the Franciscan Order. But this dating has been contested by many scholars who
put these frescoes earlier, during the pontificate of Nicholas IV, which means
in the early 1290s. We know that, in the main Assisi work sites, starting with
The Stories of Isaac, the technique of fresco painting based on the use of "giornate"
(day's work) had definitely replaced the a secco (on dry plaster) technique
(or, in any case, the widespread use of background painting a secco) that advanced
by "pontate" (sections). The new procedure had resulted in abandoning
the traditional, rigid graphic schemes, worked out over the centuries and codified
in the treatises on Byzantine painting techniques. As a consequence, it became
necessary to adjust the drawings of the images to be painted. It was the duty
of the maestro to invent and draw the images while the actual painting on the
wall was generally left to his assistants with their various levels of specialization
according to the experience each of them had acquired. Thus at Assisi the idea
was born of a different organization of the work site, an organization that
will find a novel development in the Scrovegni Chapel.
|